Are you struggling to organize your company data in one place? You’re not alone.
Today, it’s essential to use the right tools to find and organize your data. Bonus points if you can get multiple teams to use the same data catalog to streamline the process and make more informed decisions.
How do you pick the right data management tool for your business needs, then?
In this blog, we are doing a full comparison between Select Star and Secoda, two popular options in data discovery and management to present their key functionalities and how they compare in six key factors:
Let's see how they stack up!
Select Star is a data catalog that helps you find, organize, and understand your data. As a comprehensive data management platform, it allows data analysts to be more efficient while also making it easier to set up a data-driven culture in the company.
As a platform, it has a quick set up, is easy to use, and aims to streamline your data management process.
Select Star has received great feedback about its data lineage and finding exactly where the data is going, especially with the column-level data lineage.
For many data teams, Select Star helps them connect their data models with business metrics to help everyone have visibility on the calculation of KPIs.
Secoda is a data catalog and lineage portal built for data teams that want to integrate, find, and share knowledge.
As a data enablement platform, it aims to empower data-informed decisions with its all-in-one data catalog, lineage, and documentation workspace.
Secoda helps you find and organize all the data in one place to break down the silos and allow everyone to use data more effectively.
For data teams, you can use it to share domain knowledge, improve documentation, and make the most of your tech stack with various integrations.
For everyone else in the company, it makes data more accessible by simplifying the ability to search for all company data.
Secoda’s users love its simple interface, its collaboration features, its natural language search and the ease of use for everyone in the company.
Select Star vs Secoda Comparison
How is Select Star compared to Secoda in tech integrations? And how is Secoda compared to Select Star in customer support? We focus on six key categories to review Select Star and Secoda to help you pick the best product for your business needs.
The primary audience for both products is a company’s data team, from the Head of Data to the Data Analyst.
Secoda is also expanding to a wider audience to include data consumers and everyone who would benefit from exploring and using the available data within the company. For example, you can use natural language search and visualization tools to simplify the search and understanding of data.
Select Star is targeting more technical users who are comfortable with SQL-based analytics to make the most of the tool and its integrations.
Ultimately, the choice between Secoda vs Select Star depends on your specific needs and your level of technical expertise. But we’ll give more points to Secoda due to it’s aim to include a business audience.
There is a wide range of integrations both on Select Star and Secoda to improve your data stack.
For example, both tools integrate with cloud data warehouses such as Snowflake, BigQuery, Redshift and Databricks. They also integrate with tools like Tableau, PowerBI, Looker, Data Studio, and dbt.
Sigma is currently available on Select Star and it’s coming soon for Secoda.
Overall, Secoda presents several integrations that are coming soon on its website. If you are looking for a particular integration that’s not currently available, you may have to wait a bit longer. However, the number of integrations coming soon indicates that they are ambitious and want to include as many integrations as possible in the near future.
It’s good to mention that the number of integrations doesn’t determine the quality of the platform. It’s up to you to define your tech needs and the tools that are essential for your business.
Both tools have a free plan, which is useful if you want to try them on your own before you pick the one that works best for your company.
For Select Star, the free plan offers 1 data source and up to 100 tables and 10 users. For Secoda, the free plan offers 1 integration, 1 user or admin, up to 20 viewers and unlimited tables.
When it comes to paid plans, Select Star offers Pro, an entry package at $270/month for smaller businesses that don’t need more than 2 data sources, 250 tables and 50 users. This is a good plan if you are just getting started or if you have a small team. Their Growth plan is the most popular option at $810/month with 3 data sources and up to 1000 tables and 100 users. This is the best plan for you if you want to improve your data stack or use Select Star with SAML SSO Login and API access.
Secoda’s first paid plan starts at $800/month with up to 10 editors and admins, 3 integrations, and unlimited tables. You can also benefit from Slack integration, Workspace analytics, and API access.
The most popular options for both plans are in the same price range and they are targeting small to midsize companies that want a comprehensive tool for data management. For larger companies, both Select Star and Secoda offer customized enterprise plans.
As you can see, there isn’t a clear winner in this category.
Ease of Use
What both tools have in common is the user-friendly interface and the features that make it easy for users to view and understand their data.
As we mentioned just earlier in the ‘Target Audience’ section, Select Star is targeting a more technical audience while Secoda is broadening the audience to everyone in the company who wants to find and manage their data. This is why Secoda emphasizes the importance of providing a clean and easy-to-use interface to appeal to both technical and non-technical users.
“I love how easy to use their platform is. In a single afternoon we were able to get set up and get our company onboarded. Now the entire company doesn't need to rely on our data team which was struggling to keep up.”
- Adi P.
Secoda was rated 8/10 in ease of use at G2. Meanwhile, Select Star received very positive reviews from its (more technical) users with a rating of 9/10 in ease of use at G2.
“Selectstar is super user friendly and fast. Easy for me to navigate our and understand our tables.”
- Verified user in wholesale
We are giving more points to Select Star based on the users’ higher rating on Ease of Use on G2.
Review and Ratings
Let’s see what customers think about the two products. We looked at G2.com, an established site for product reviews, to explore the ratings and reviews for Select Star and Secoda.
Both tools have generally positive feedback from users and they are also included in G2’s High Performer Winter 2023 awards in the Machine Learning Data Catalog category. Secoda has a score of 4.4 from 18 reviews while Select Star is slightly ahead with a score of 4.5 from 27 reviews.
Select Star received positive reviews on its ease of use, its integrations, and its data lineage.
“Select Star gives the best view of data lineage for all the connected tools. Another important feature was for documenting the metrics and summary which is very useful if multiple teams are working across the company.”
“For us, it was the integration with the tools that we have in our data platform. They had native integrations so it was super quick to integrate and start using Select Star.”
- Verified user in logistics & supply chain
Secoda’s users love its ease of use, its natural language search, and the collaboration features.
“Secoda is an excellent tool as it has many different features which allow for each company to utilize the product how best suits them.”
“The goal of having an actual 1-stop data workspace for all our data users feels realistically within our grasp now, thanks to the breadth of the offering and the platform's user-centric, intuitive nature.”
It was a tough category to pick a winner but we’re sticking to the users’ reviews for the overall rating.
Service and Support
Both Select Star and Secoda offer live chat and resources on their sites to answer their customers’ questions. They receive good feedback about their support and how they go beyond the way to help their customers.
Select Star was rated 9.6/10 on G2 in Quality of Support based on 22 reviews.
“The Select Star team is super helpful, so don't hesitate to ask them your most difficult questions!”
- Verified user in computer software
Secoda doesn’t have enough reviews yet to be rated in the specific category but its users find the support very helpful.
As a newer tool, they acknowledge that it’s still a work in progress but the customer team tries to make up for it.
“They have been super helpful and if there were any small road bumps we've run into, the Secoda support team was quick to respond and provide a solution.”
- Verified user in computer software
It’s worth mentioning that both products only promise dedicated customer support or access to an account manager for their Enterprise package.
The Best Data Catalog for Your Business
Select Star vs Secoda - who wins? Well, there isn’t a clear winner, but Select Star wins by a narrow margin.
If you’re currently looking for the best tool to find, organize, and understand your data, we have another highly-rated recommendation for you. CastorDoc is a top data discovery and catalog platform that brings together the top features from both Select Star and Secoda.
With a rating of 4.7/5 from G2 users, it stands out with its ease of use (10/10 from G2 users!), its polished user interface, but also its locking of documentation between tools, its integrations, and customer support.
CastorDoc won G2’s award ‘Winter 2023 G2 Leader’ in the Machine Learning Data Catalog category and it’s targeting both technical and non-technical users who want to simplify the process of finding and using data within the company. It’s a plug-and-play data catalog that serves as the single source of reference for all your data and the mass business adoption makes it a proven market leader.
Ready to improve your data experience? Try CastorDoc today with a free 14-day trial to discover how it can help your business make smarter decisions.
Fantastic tool for data discovery and documentation
“[I like] The easy to use interface and the speed of finding the relevant assets that you're looking for in your database. I also really enjoy the score given to each table, [which] lets you prioritize the results of your queries by how often certain data is used.”
Michal, Head of Data, Printify