Data Strategy
Build vs. Buy Data Catalog: What Should Factor Into Your Decision Making?

Build vs. Buy Data Catalog: What Should Factor Into Your Decision Making?

Discover the key factors to consider when deciding between building or buying a data catalog for your organization.

Organizations are increasingly recognizing the importance of having a well-organized and easily accessible data catalog. A data catalog serves as a centralized repository that provides valuable information about the data assets within an organization. It helps users, such as data scientists, analysts, and business users, in discovering, understanding, and effectively utilizing the available data.

Understanding the Basics of Data Catalogs

Data catalogs can be defined as a comprehensive inventory of all the data assets within an organization. They provide detailed information about the structure, format, and content of the data, as well as the data lineage and relationships between different datasets. A data catalog acts as a bridge between technical metadata, such as database schemas and table structures, and business metadata, such as data definitions and business glossaries.

Data catalogs are not just limited to structured data, but also include various types of unstructured and semi-structured data like documents, images, and audio files. They enable users to quickly search for relevant datasets, understand their quality and reliability, and access them in a secure and governed manner.

Defining Data Catalogs

A data catalog is a well-organized inventory of all the datasets available within an organization. It provides a unified view of the data landscape and helps users in discovering, evaluating, and utilizing the available data assets. The catalog includes detailed metadata about each dataset, such as its source, structure, format, and accessibility.

Data catalogs also capture information about data ownership, data sensitivity, and compliance requirements. They serve as a critical component of data governance and enable organizations to enforce data policies, ensure data quality, and comply with regulatory requirements.

Importance of Data Catalogs in Business

Data catalogs play a crucial role in enabling organizations to become more data-driven and make informed business decisions. They provide several key benefits:

  1. Improved Data Discovery: With a data catalog, users can easily search and discover relevant datasets, saving time and effort searching through multiple systems and databases.
  2. Enhanced Data Understanding: Data catalogs provide comprehensive metadata that helps users understand the structure, content, and context of the available data assets. This understanding is essential for effective data analysis and decision making.
  3. Promoting Data Collaboration: Data catalogs foster collaboration and knowledge sharing among teams by providing a common platform for accessing and discussing data. This leads to better insights and more accurate decision making.
  4. Ensuring Data Governance: Data catalogs facilitate the enforcement of data governance policies by capturing information about data ownership, access controls, and compliance requirements. This helps organizations maintain data privacy, security, and regulatory compliance.

Furthermore, data catalogs also support data lineage tracking, which allows organizations to trace the origin and transformation of data throughout its lifecycle. This capability is especially valuable in industries with strict regulatory requirements, such as finance and healthcare, where data lineage is crucial for ensuring data integrity and compliance.

In addition to facilitating data governance and compliance, data catalogs also contribute to improving data quality. By providing a centralized repository of metadata, organizations can establish data quality standards and monitor the accuracy, completeness, and consistency of their data assets. This proactive approach to data quality management helps organizations identify and resolve data issues before they impact business operations or decision making.

Moreover, data catalogs enable organizations to leverage their data assets more effectively. By providing a clear understanding of the available data, including its structure, format, and accessibility, data catalogs empower users to select the most appropriate datasets for their analytical needs. This not only saves time and effort but also enhances the accuracy and reliability of data-driven insights.

The Build Approach to Data Catalogs

When considering implementing a data catalog, organizations have two fundamental options: building their own solution or buying a pre-built data catalog software. Each approach has its advantages and disadvantages that need careful consideration.

Building a data catalog in-house offers several benefits:

  • Customization: Building your own solution allows you to tailor the data catalog to your specific needs, ensuring it aligns perfectly with your organization's data landscape and business requirements.
  • Flexibility: With an in-house data catalog, you have the flexibility to adapt and extend the functionality as your organization's data requirements evolve over time.
  • Cost Control: Building your own solution can potentially save on licensing costs, especially for large organizations with extensive data catalogs or complex data environments.

However, there are some challenges associated with the build approach:

  • Resource Intensive: Building a data catalog requires significant investment in terms of time, resources, and technical expertise. It may require a dedicated team with data engineering and software development skills.
  • Complexity: Developing a data catalog from scratch involves managing various technical components and integrating them with existing data systems. This complexity can lead to delays and increased development efforts.
  • Maintenance and Support: Once built, the data catalog needs ongoing maintenance and support, which can be a drain on resources and divert attention away from core business activities.

Despite these challenges, many organizations opt for the build approach due to the unique advantages it offers. By building their own data catalog, organizations can have complete control over the design and functionality of the system. This level of customization ensures that the data catalog perfectly aligns with the specific needs and requirements of the organization.

Furthermore, the flexibility provided by the build approach allows organizations to adapt and extend the data catalog as their data landscape evolves. With the ability to add new features and functionalities, organizations can ensure that their data catalog remains relevant and effective in supporting their data management goals.

While the initial investment in building a data catalog may be resource-intensive, it can lead to long-term cost savings. By avoiding licensing fees associated with pre-built data catalog software, organizations can allocate their budget towards other critical areas of their data management initiatives.

However, it is important to acknowledge the complexity involved in building a data catalog from scratch. It requires expertise in data engineering and software development to successfully integrate the catalog with existing data systems and ensure its seamless operation. Organizations must be prepared for the challenges that come with managing and coordinating various technical components.

Additionally, once the data catalog is built, ongoing maintenance and support become crucial. Organizations must allocate resources to ensure that the catalog remains up-to-date, secure, and aligned with changing data requirements. This ongoing commitment to maintenance and support can divert attention and resources away from core business activities, requiring careful planning and resource allocation.

In conclusion, the build approach to data catalogs offers organizations the opportunity to create a customized and flexible solution that aligns perfectly with their unique data landscape and business requirements. While it requires significant investment and ongoing maintenance, the benefits of control, customization, and potential cost savings make it a compelling option for many organizations.

The Buy Approach to Data Catalogs

Alternatively, organizations can opt to buy a pre-built data catalog software from a vendor. This approach offers its own set of advantages and disadvantages.

Advantages of Buying a Data Catalog

Buying a pre-built data catalog software provides several benefits:

  • Rapid Deployment: A pre-built solution can be quickly implemented, allowing organizations to start realizing the benefits of a data catalog sooner.
  • Out-of-the-box Functionality: Pre-built data catalog software often comes with a wide range of features and functionalities, reducing the need for extensive customization.
  • Vendor Support: When you buy a data catalog software, you gain access to vendor support and maintenance services, ensuring any technical issues are addressed promptly.

Disadvantages of Buying a Data Catalog

However, there are a few considerations to keep in mind when buying a data catalog:

  • Vendor Dependency: By buying a pre-built solution, you become dependent on the vendor for updates, maintenance, and support. This can potentially lead to additional costs and limited control over the software.
  • Cost Considerations: Licensing costs can be a significant factor when buying a data catalog software, especially for organizations with large datasets or a large number of users.

Key Factors to Consider in Your Decision

Before making a decision between building or buying a data catalog, it is crucial to consider several key factors.

Assessing Your Business Needs

Understand your organization's specific data catalog requirements. Consider the size of your data catalog, the complexity of your data landscape, and the specific features and functionalities that are crucial for your business.

Look at the importance of customization, scalability, and integration capabilities and how these align with your organization's future growth and technology roadmap.

Evaluating Your Budget

Determine the total cost of ownership for both the build and buy options. Consider initial development costs, ongoing maintenance, support, and licensing fees. Evaluate the financial implications and assess the budget available for implementing and maintaining a data catalog.

Considering Your Technical Capabilities

Analyze the technical expertise available within your organization. Assess whether you have the necessary skill sets to develop and maintain a data catalog in-house. Evaluate the existing data management infrastructure, data integration capabilities, and data governance frameworks.

If your organization lacks the required technical capabilities, consider the additional investment needed to upskill your internal team or hire external expertise.

Making the Final Decision: Build or Buy?

The decision between building or buying a data catalog should take into account a variety of factors. Here are a few key considerations:

Weighing the Pros and Cons

Compare the pros and cons of building and buying a data catalog based on your organization's specific requirements, budget, and technical capabilities. Consider the customization needs, long-term scalability, maintenance and support requirements, and financial implications of each approach.

Aligning Your Decision with Business Goals

Think about how a data catalog aligns with your overall business goals and objectives. Consider how it will enhance data-driven decision making, improve collaboration, enable compliance, and support innovation and growth.

Implementing Your Chosen Data Catalog Solution

Once you have made the final decision, it is essential to meticulously plan and execute the implementation of your chosen data catalog solution. Define a clear roadmap, allocate resources, and establish governance processes to ensure a successful and smooth implementation.

Remember to involve key stakeholders from various departments to ensure the data catalog meets the needs of all users and delivers on the desired outcomes.


A data catalog is a crucial component of a modern data-driven organization. Whether you choose to build your own data catalog or buy a pre-built solution, ensure you carefully consider the key factors discussed in this article.

By making an informed decision based on your specific business needs, budget, and technical capabilities, you can set your organization on the path to better data management, improved decision making, and enhanced collaboration.

New Release
Table of Contents

You might also like

Get in Touch to Learn More

See Why Users Love CastorDoc
Fantastic tool for data discovery and documentation

“[I like] The easy to use interface and the speed of finding the relevant assets that you're looking for in your database. I also really enjoy the score given to each table, [which] lets you prioritize the results of your queries by how often certain data is used.” - Michal P., Head of Data